It depends on what you are going for. As far as marketing, whatever feels more dynamic works best, so overloading something with cool effects help achieve that. With that said, I also like his better, you can appreciate the details of the drawing MUCH better
You are such an amazing artist, thank you so much for uploading your work!
Spamming effects all over it takes away from it, and doesn't really make it more "dynamic" just more spammy.
I do get you though. :3
But yea, sometimes people go crazy with effects just to gain attention.